Making an album about love while you’re still in the thick of it takes guts. Courtney Marie Andrews has never backed away from that kind of honesty. She’s spent over a decade navigating Americana’s dusty highways and indie-folk’s quieter corners, building her reputation on plain truths and difficult admissions. Valentine, her eleventh record, tackles the messiest territory yet: grief colliding with new romance, vulnerability that terrifies, the exhausting refusal to shrink yourself for someone else’s comfort.
Recorded largely to tape with co-producer Jerry Bernhardt, these songs sound like they were made by actual people in an actual room. You can hear the air between instruments, the slight imperfections that give everything texture. Andrews points to Big Star’s haunted Third and Fleetwood Mac’s sprawling Tusk as guiding lights, and both albums’ resistance to easy polish shows up here. The arrangements are lush but never overthought. Flutes drift through Little Picture of a Butterfly, synths shimmer underneath Outsider, and Andrews’ voice carries the weight, shifting from theatrical sweep to intimate whisper sometimes within a single verse.
Pendulum Swing opens the record and immediately sets the stakes. “If I get what I want, gotta let the pendulum swing,” she sings, already pushing back against optimism’s easier path. Love on this album isn’t salvation. It requires clear eyes even when your heart wants to blur everything soft. The production is warm, almost vintage, but Andrews’ voice cuts through with modern precision.
Country inflections and quivering vocal sighs shape Keeper, where she questions whether her devotion will ever be matched. Then Cons & Clowns arrives, possibly the album’s emotional centre. Over acoustic guitar that echoes Kate Bush’s gentler work, Andrews builds a protective space around her lover: “It’s a scary world full of cons and clowns / a lot of bad people who will tear you down / not me, no way.” The tenderness shifts into something fiercer. “Don’t make yourself small, baby, take up space.” She’s offering the kind of love that demands you show up fully, that refuses diminishment for anyone’s comfort.
The Lee Hazlewood influence surfaces clearest on Magic Touch and Outsider. Andrews explores the gap between wanting to belong and actually fitting anywhere. Los Angeles takes a hit (“no drugs or money could fill this void inside me”), while the existential question hangs: “How could I be an insider / when I don’t fit in?” The melody carries ABBA-worthy melancholy wrapped in dreamy atmosphere, turning alienation into something genuinely affecting.
Everyone Wants to Feel Like You Do channels heartland rock, borrowing from Tom Petty’s playbook of making specific situations feel universal. Playful, satirical, pointing fingers at masculine bravado and its inevitable wreckage. Andrews then strips everything back for Best Friend, just voice and guitar, aching for “someone to laugh with at bad jokes only we get.” The loneliness cuts deep.
The album could easily collapse under its emotional weight, but Andrews’ fundamental refusal to wallow keeps pulling it back. She’s probing depths that risk sentimentality. The vulnerability sometimes borders on painful. Yet her humour keeps surfacing, along with her commitment to clear-eyed observation. On Only the Best, she lays everything bare: “I’m a masochist, I’m a marionette, I’m a mess making moves on you.” The self-awareness disarms you. She knows exactly what she’s risking, knows she’s showing her cards, does it regardless.
Hangman closes things out. “Don’t wanna live playing hangman / Always asking for vowels / On the edge of death / without the truth spelled out.” After ten tracks circling love’s complications, she lands on radical honesty as the only viable option. The final line, “I have loved you from the beginning,” feels earned rather than sentimental. The whole record has been building toward this: not easy answers, just the willingness to say the true thing even when it leaves you completely exposed.
Andrews sang with uncanny wisdom on Honest Life back when she was barely 25. Now in her early thirties, Grammy-nominated and critically acclaimed, she’s pushed into new sonic territory while keeping what made her essential. The voice remains unmistakable, that aching clarity. The writing still refuses sugar-coating. But Valentine sounds bigger, more ambitious, incorporating jazz harmonies and new-age textures and Lindsey Buckingham’s baroque dreaminess without losing focus.
This is middle-of-the-road radio with genuine daring underneath, the kind of music that could slot into daytime playlists while sneaking in real innovation. The album understands love as something built over years, through trust and change and the hard work of staying honest when honesty draws blood. Andrews won’t promise you’ll get what you want. She won’t pretend the world lacks cons and clowns. But she’ll stand in your corner, refusing to make herself small, showing you how to take up space. Maybe that’s not romantic in the traditional sense, but right now it feels pretty close to revolutionary.
Valentine is out today via Thirty Tigers.
Share this :
