The Dresden Dolls @ Beanfield Theatre▪

The last time The Dresden Dolls came to Montreal was the week I moved here, all the way back in January 2008, and I couldn’t make it; I’ve been waiting for them to come back ever since. It’s been almost 19 years, but finally, tonight, the wait is over!

The duo of pianist Amanda Palmer and drummer Brian Viglione arrive on stage flooded in bright white light, which is quite the contrast to their dark, gothic cabaret sound. They set up at the foot of a giant banner at the back of the stage that features the artwork of their 2006 sophomore record Yes, Virginia…, recently re-recorded and celebrating its 20th anniversary this year. The stop-start burlesque Sex Changes gets things going in anthemic manner, a perfect encapsulation of their sound which was like nothing I’ve ever heard before when I first discovered them back in 2004. To be honest, I’ve not heard anything like it since either. Brian’s drums are a perfect foil to Amanda’s piano, often driving the melody, especially on songs like Modern Moonlight, which are so furious and complex, you’d think there were 2 drummers if you closed your eyes.

Amanda explains how they met at a Halloween party in 2000, so tonight technically marks the 26th birthday of the band. To celebrate, the band bring out a cake and sing “Happy Birthday to Band,” before throwing out slices to the crowd to enjoy. There truly is a community vibe to the show all evening. Just 3 songs in, the outro to My Alcoholic Friends sees a gaggle of friends appear from the side of the stage with shot glasses, passing one to Amanda as they raise a glass in unison before downing them, and then reappear on the anthemic Sing, to, well, sing.

I’m usually one to complain if a band wastes too much time on cover versions, and ordinarily, I would complain that FIVE is way too many. But tonight, it just fits. And with a set that clocks in at 2½ hours, there’s plenty of time for them without sacrificing the original songs you really want to hear. Amanda and Brian open up about their artistic influences early on in the set, which sets the scene nicely for the covers that follow. Kurt Weill’s Pirate Jenny is apparently over 100 years old, yet its spooky narrative fits into the set immaculately, while the obvious Rocky Horror Picture Show link is confirmed with the inclusion of Science Fiction/Double Feature. “Because it’s Halloween and we’re in Montreal, we’re gonna do something weird,” announces Amanda; a slick rendition of Françoise Hardy’s Tous les garçons et les filles follows. Nine Inch Nails’ Hurt resonates, particularly in light of Amanda’s mention of recent legal battles with her ex-husband. But the highlight of the bunch has to be Jacques Brel’s Amsterdam. On the darkened stage, Brian leaves his drum kit with an acoustic guitar, wandering to the front, before Amanda suddenly appears on the balcony at the left of the stage, spotlight on her in true theatrical fashion as she raises a beer to the crowd, while, again, singing all in French. It’s an impressive feat; at the song’s conclusion, Amanda returns to her piano, and a voice in the crowd asks “how do you follow that?!”

“With a really great Dresden Dolls song!” is Amanda’s reply. California Shores follows; she’s not wrong! Brian leaves the stage to Amanda to play an emotional Me & The Minibar solo, before returning for a pummelling Necessary Evil. A couple of new songs make an appearance too, in the form of Houdini, which follows a similar structure to their classic Mrs O, and The Runner, which is more delicate with muffled drums, but feels magical in conjunction with intermittent pulsing spotlights that twinkle like stars.

When the classics land, though… wow. Coin-Operated Boy is still one of the most unusual alternative songs I know, sounding like a nursery rhyme until both Amanda and Brian start messing up the timing to give the effect of a skipping record; Brian pulls a creepy grinning doll face throughout to add to the vibe. Half Jack is a simmering masterpiece that broods all the way to that triumphant chorus, and Girl Anachronism, the song which hooked me onto the band all those years ago when I saw it played live on some random TV show, closes out the evening in frenetic manner.

A truly phenomenal evening from start to finish; well worth the 19-year wait!

Setlist

  1. Sex Changes
  2. Missed Me
  3. My Alcoholic Friends
  4. Mrs. O
  5. First Orgasm
  6. Coin-Operated Boy
  7. Pirate Jenny (Kurt Weill cover)
  8. Modern Moonlight
  9. Amsterdam (Jacques Brel cover)
  10. Shores of California
  11. Tous les garçons et les filles (Françoise Hardy cover)
  12. Me & The Minibar
  13. Necessary Evil
  14. Houdini
  15. The Runner
  16. Backstabber
  17. Mandy Goes to Med School
  18. Science Fiction/Double Feature (Richard O’Brien cover)
  19. Sing

Encore

  1. Hurt (Nine Inch Nails cover)
  2. Half Jack
  3. Girl Anachronism

Review & photos by Simon Williams

Share this :
FacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailFacebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail